Showing posts with label LCBO. Show all posts
Showing posts with label LCBO. Show all posts

Saturday, November 3, 2007

You can't always get want you want...


Wanted : A hard to find White Burgundy, which was really good but doesn't exist in our harsh Ontario wine climate...

Friday night I drove out to Oakville which is about 40 KM from Hamilton to pick up a wine that I was looking for.

Here is the LCBO details on it -

BOUCHARD PÈRE ET FILS LES COTEAUX DES MOINES BOURGOGNE 2005
VINTAGES 29769
750 mL bottle
Price: $ 18.95
13.5% Alcohol
Vol.Sugar Content : XD
Made in: Burgundy, France
By: Bouchard Pere & Fils
Release Date: May 12, 2007

Description: In 2005, the conditions in Burgundy were ideal for properly ripening Chardonnay. This resulted in wines, displaying wonderfully intense apple, mineral, pear and smoky notes. Enjoy this fruit-forward wine with roasted stuffed chicken.

As I mentioned in my 1010 article, I had tried this wine at Thanksgiving and really enjoyed it. According to the LCBO's database there were 8 bottles in stock at the Dundas & Trafalgar (Oak Park) location in Oakville. This was closest location to me with stock. After a forty minute drive I reached the store. I was impressed at the size of the LCBO, about the same size as the Ancaster location I usually shop at (though small compared to Prime wines in Kenmore).

I browsed through the Burgundy section and found three different Bouchard Pere & Fils (including the Petit-Chabis I had the 1010 last night and grabbed a bottle) but not the Bourgogne I was looking for. I hit the Vintages section a did some browsing but couldn't find it.

I did find that they had The Henry of Pelham 2005 Botrytis Affected Riesling (Vintages #534628 $34.95 for 375mL) in stock and grabbed a bottle to replace the one I tried about a month ago. Do yourself a favour and pick up one of these up, it is truly excellent - pair with a fruit based dessert (Apple is really good), cheese cake or any other non-chocolate based dessert, this will also go well with a Blue Cheese.

I noticed that the Riesling had a little sign that said "Melissa's pick" and thought to myself that Melissa has great taste. I also found a bottle of The Noble by D'Arenberg, it too is a Botrytis Affect Riesling, and picked it up. I ended up grabbing two bottles of D'Arenberg 2006 'Hermit Crab' Viognier (Vintages 662775, 750 mL bottle, Price: $ 16.95). I had the 2005 Hermit Crab three months ago and liked it.

I decided to find some help and grabbed a cashier who looked it up and then we went looking for it, no luck. She called another staff member over who happened to be 'the Melissa' who had a number of picks in the Vintages section. Melissa told me she was aware of the wine I was looking for, knew that the system had listed 8 bottles but had looked for them earlier and had no luck. I told her I drove in from Hamilton especially for this, she replied that I should have called first. I replied that I know the LCBO database can be out and if there were less than 6 bottles listed I would have called but figured with eight listed that I should have been safe. I wasn't happy.

To give Melissa credit, she handled this wonderfully - "Maybe I can recommend something similiar?"

As I had agreed with her pick on the Riesling earlier, I decided to see what she had to offer. We ended up back in the Vintages section and chatted, she said that 2005 was an excellent year for White Burgundy and then offered a Louis Jadot 2005 Bourgogne (Vintages 933077, 750 mL bottle, Price: $ 18.95) as replacement for what I was looking for. It was the same price as the Bouchard Pere & Fils and Louis Jadot is a large, well known producer so I grabbed 3 bottles.

We chatted some more and she also recommended a Joseph Drouhin Puligny-Montrachet 2005 (Vintages 51383, 750 mL bottle, Price: $ 64.95, 13.5% Alcohol, Vol.Sugar Content : XD, Made in: Burgundy, France). She said it was pricier than what I was looking for but if I liked California Chardonnay then I would love this. So I picked up a bottle, I have a couple of higher end California Chardonnays on the rack and thought that a dinner with two of them facing off might be fun. There was another wine by Joseph Drouhin beside this one called St. Romain Blanc 2005 (Vintages 590174, 750 mL bottle, Price: $ 28.95, 12.5% Alcohol, Vol.Sugar Content : XD, Made in: Burgundy, France) so on a whim picked one up.

I thanked Melissa for her help, paid for the wine and left. I didn't get what I wanted, but left feeling very excited about the wines I'd picked up.

Cheers!

Mark

Wednesday, October 24, 2007

The LCBO - Part 5

This is the final part of the LCBO series. In the last article, I pointed out things I liked and disliked about the LCBO. This final part will deal with some ideas I have on how to improve the LCBO or how to change the system.

The ideal solution in my mind would be to privatize the LCBO but as I stated my reasons in the first part of the series, I don't think that will be happening anytime soon.

So time to 'think outside the box'...

1. Remove Beer from the LCBO, I'd be tempted to add wine/vodka coolers or any beverages under 7% alcohol. The will force the LCBO to focus on Wine and Liquor and dedicate their efforts in both departments.

2. Allow regional based specialty wines to stores to be opened privately. Example of this is a wine store that sells nothing but French wines. This will increase the selection of wines available to Ontario consumers and leave the LCBO in public selling its general selection of wines. It will also allow regional experts to pass on their knowledge of a region to Ontario consumers; as I have to imagine that someone opening a regional wine store would be very familiar with the region.

3. Allow easy web-based shopping via the LCBO's website. You can order and pay online and then pickup your order at the LCBO of your choice. Have on the website a section called "Can't find a wine..." where you can click and send an e-mail with the wine you are looking for, and have staff that specializes in tracking down wines.

If anyone is reading this and has another suggestion, leave a comment and I will add it to the list.

Cheers!

Mark

The LCBO - Part 4

In the first three parts, I covered the three objectives of the LCBO and how these could still be achieved under a privatized system. This part was supposed to discuss what I felt is wrong with the LCBO, but I don't want to just be negative so I've decided to discuss the good points of the LCBO as well.

The last time the topic privatization came up under the Harris government, the LCBO went through a number of changes. They modernized their signs and stores from the old plain blue and white to their current green and white/beige look. Some of the stores before the makeover looked dirty and old. The current LCBO's are all very clean and modern looking. They opened on Sundays and have longer hours of operation; they started accepting Debit and Credit cards. They now offer Air Miles on purchases. They have a website and web-based searchable inventory system. Their product inventory has gotten better over the years.

In short there have been a lot of improvements to the LCBO over the last 10-15 years. For that I will give them credit.

This still doesn't change the fact that they have a monopoly on imported liquor and wine in the province Ontario. It doesn't change the fact that their unionized workforce lags behind in service levels vs. private sector retail. It doesn't change the fact that Ontario consumers are paying more for wine than they should and while their selection has gotten better, it is still far too limited.

Here is a few of the issues I have with the LCBO...

1. There has been an alarming trend for LCBO stores to increase the size of their beer selections to the detriment of their wine floor space. (There are Brewers Retails/Beers Stores where you can buy beer, but there is only one place you can buy imported wine).

2. There web based inventory system is good but it has a few short comings - inventory levels aren't 100% accurate, they are slow to purge out inventory items which they have no stock (and aren't getting any more) from the system, the search isn't as flexible on search criteria as it could be, you can't right click on a link in search and open it in a new window (this would be very useful to compare products).

3. There should be a way to order products that are listed online and have them shipped to your nearest LCBO.

4. Customer service... here is two examples of problems with LCBO customer service - I found a wine that I wanted located at Toronto store as none of the local stores had stock. I went to my local LCBO after work, and asked them to transfer 12 bottles from the Toronto store. The lady told me that the product manager had gone home for the day and to come back tomorrow. I had the store number, the product, and all the details they needed, I would have quite happily pre-paid for the wine, but yet she couldn't take this information and give it to the product manager when he was in next. Instead, I had to make a trip up on my lunch hour to do this.

The next example is my favorite... there was a brand of wine that I read nice things about their Merlot. I had tried this brand's Chardonnay and really want to try the Merlot. I did a search and found that the LCBO doesn't carry the Merlot for this brand. I decided to go to my local LCBO, to see if they could help me. In the end the person helping me, gave me the name and number of the agent who imports the wines for this brand and then sells it to the LCBO. Two problems with this - Wine agents usually only order by the case, and I just wanted to try a bottle and why the hell should I do the leg work and calling around... I’m not in the business of selling wine - they are.

Now both of these are small points but neither of them would have happened in a regular retail environment.

There a store in Kenmore NY called the Prime Wines and is part of the Premier Group. If you live in Southern Ontario and like wines make the trip. The Prime Wines store is huge; this store is like a Home Depot of wines... HUGE! The customer service is fantastic and the selection is mind-blowing. If you think the LCBO is adequately serving Ontario, one trip to Prime Wines and you'll realize how under served we are.

5. Limited selection, I have done searches on the wines on the Wine Spectator and found a list of 20 or so and found that the LCBO doesn't carry a single one of them. Here would be a classic example – in a search for South African Chenin Blanc, 5000 cases made, rated 85 or better. This will produce a list of probably 20 or more, and yet the LCBO didn't have a single one. If stores were privately owned, you could establish a relationship with the store and I sure they be able to get you in one of the twenty wines... There was a wine tasting event in Calgary (Alberta, Canada) where they judged 1000 wines under $25 and then made a list of the top 3 of each wine by grape. I did a search via the LCBO and half didn't even come up, and out of the remaining half, half of those that came up had no stock. This wine tasting was done in Calgary not California, Alberta is a smaller province than Ontario and yet we only are able to get a 1/4 of the wines on the list? Alberta has privatized liquor stores...

6. The Ontario Government has recently changed the rules and added a 20 cent deposit on wine bottles. The idea was to cut down on waste and keep wine bottles out of landfills and recycle them instead. Two problems with this - most cities in Ontario have a "Blue Box" recycling program. I know I haven't tossed a bottle in the garbage since the Blue Box program went in, and I image most Ontarians are vigilant in their recycling efforts as well so I question how many bottle were ending up in landfills. The second and biggest problem with this deposit idea - YOU CAN'T RETURN THE BOTTLE TO THE LCBO... you have to take it the Beer Store... so I have to waste more gas driving (really thinking of the environment with this plan!) to the Beer store to return my empty wine bottles.

What pisses me off the most about this, is this deposit idea was taken out of a report that Ontario's Liberal Government had commissioned to look at liquor sales and how well served the people of Ontario are by the current system. The report was like 100 pages, and the majority of the report recommended privatizing the LCBO and the deposit thing was like half a page, almost like a footnote... so of course they choose to do the deposit idea and implement it half-assed and ignore the rest of the report.... sigh.

These points seem like small issues, but as the LCBO has a monopoly on imported wines, there isn't any other option but to go New York State to buy wine to get around these issues.

The people of Ontario should have more options and this monopoly hurts Ontario consumers. We deserve better than this and it is time for a change...

Tuesday, October 23, 2007

The LCBO - Part 3

3. Supporting the domestic wine industry and providing it with incentive through differential pricing, marketing, and promotion practices.

This one can be handled in two different ways if the LCBO was privatized.

The first way is the Ontario government could mandate that a certain percentage of stock/floor space is dedicated to domestic wines in privatized stores. Similar to the way Canadian content rules are used for radio and TV airtime. Bookstores in Canada are subject to this as well.

The other way to deal with this is to stop protecting Canadian based wines altogether. We are living in a global economy and regional protectionism is very outdated thinking. This protectionism hurts the Canadian wine industry by giving them a closed market for sub par wines, and Ontario consumers by charging higher prices for imported wines to prop up the domestic market.

Ontario makes great Riesling, Late Harvest, Ice wines and some decent Chardonnay but that is it. Ontario wines are also generally overpriced, can't count the number of times I have an Ontario based wines that is good, but then see the price and think, "It was good, but not that good.." and know I can find a much better imported wine for the same price or less.

Here is a link that shows a list of wine producing countries by volume.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wine_producing_countries

Canada is 32nd in the world. I tossed around the numbers and came up with a few interesting observations - Canada produces less than 1/6th of a percent of the world's wine. Canada's total wine production is 4% of South Africa's production, Canada total wine production is less than 1% of France's total wine production.

Now with those observations, wander into your local LCBO and look at their wine sections. The South African wine section is super tiny (if it exists at all); France's wine section will be at maximum the same size as the Canadian or less. The Canadian wines usually take up 20-25% of the wine floor space of an LCBO. So Canada makes less than 1/6th of a percent of the world's wines and yet gets 20-25% of the floor space at the LCBO which is ONLY place to purchase imported wines. This isn't including the bonus of being the only wines sold in Ontario Supermarkets.

What is their motivation to make better and more competitively priced wines with these types of market bonuses???

What is really scary is most Canadian wines were over-priced when our dollar was at 63 cents vs. US dollar... now that our dollar is at par with the US; Canadian wines should be stupidly overpriced. Well, they would be if the LCBO was actually quick to pass on those savings on California wines to Ontario consumers. To be fair the LCBO has passed on some savings - a bottle of wine in the US which retails for $7.99 US, was listed at $19.95 is now listed at $17.95. Wow, a $20 wine when the dollar is at 63 cents in now is $18 when our money is at par!

STOP protecting Canadian wine... if Ontario can't make wines which are competitive on the world stage then they need to get the fuck out of the wine business.... PLEASE.

Now people reading this make think I'm being very "Un-Canadian" in my thinking, and thinking that if I love the US so much then I should just move there.

My response to that is this... I'm a confident and proud Canadian. I have no doubt in my mind that our Rieslings and Dessert wines can easily compete on the world stage. Stop planting vines in Niagara that don't grow well (Cabernet Sauvignon for example) and focus on making the best damn Rieslings and dessert wines on the planet. The only way this is going to happen is if we stop protecting them...

Cheers!


Mark.

The LCBO - Part 2

2. Balancing regulatory control with the need to raise revenue for the provincial and federal governments through profits and taxes on alcohol sale;

The point above,basically means the LCBO is in business to make money for provincial and federal governments.

The LCBO Employees Union loves to talk about how much money is raised by the LCBO and if we privatized it, all that revenue would go away.

This is a half truth at best…. when I go to NY state and buy wine, once I reach customs on my way back and pay duty on the wine there is a line on the bill called LCBO markup charge.

Last time I was in NY buying wine here was the break down on the duty...

Value of wine in CDN dollars - $1160.70

Excise Tax - $11.16
GST - $70.31
Provincial (LCBO) Markup fee - $464.06
Provincial sales tax - $196.31

Total duty - $741.84

So the province of Ontario between the markup fee and sales tax got - $660.37 without an LCBO employee handling a single bottle!

This markup charge is in those profit number that the LCBO Employees Union talks about. So if the LCBO didn’t exist the government would still get a good chunk of that revenue (via alcohol taxes) that is currently gets from the LCBO.

Cheers!

Mark.

The LCBO - Part 1

There are two things I hate about Ontario and wine - Ontario wines and the LCBO. For those of you unfamiliar with the LCBO (Liquer Control Board of Ontario)... please give this a read http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LCBO .

The LCBO is a government run monopoly on alcohol. I do not believe they are doing a good job in serving the province of Ontario and changes need to be made.

Ideally, I would like to see them privatize the LCBO. I don't believe this will happen as Employees Union of the LCBO works very hard at putting out propaganda every time privatization issue comes up, the Government itself loves having the LCBO around for patronage appointments, and lastly the voters in Ontario are too apathetic to force the change.

I found the following on a report done for the Ontario Liquor Boards Employees' Union. ( http://www.yorku.ca/nuri/lcbo.htm )

The objectives and concerns of the LCBO are basically the following:

1. Regulatory control of the sales of alcohol to protect society;

2. Balancing regulatory control with the need to raise revenue for the provincial and federal governments through profits and taxes on alcohol sale;

3. Supporting the domestic wine industry and providing it with incentive through differential pricing, marketing, and promotion practices.

I am going to break this blog up into five parts - the first three will deal with each of the objectives, the fourth will deal with what is wrong with the current system and the last will be about suggestions I have for changing things with the LCBO.

So lets get started - 1. Regulatory control of the sales of alcohol to protect society;

Whenever the topic of privatization comes up this first point is a favourite for Ontario Liquor Boards Employees' Union propaganda, I call it the "Think of the Children" argument.

The "Think of the Children" argument is basically this - if booze was sold in convenience stores the restrictions on alcohol to minors would be much more relaxed than it currently is. They like to make out that minors would be buying booze buy the caseload, teen alcoholism rates would go through the ceiling, instead of packing a drinking box of Orange Tang in their lunches they'd switch to bottle of Vodka to get them through the day... Oh whoa is me!

The answer to this is simple - don't sell booze in convenience stores, instead require stores that carry booze to be stand alone stores. If your whole business and livelihood centered on having a valid liquor license, how relaxed would you be in I.D'ing minors?

Also this "Think of the Children" argument is bullshit anyways... when I was 16 and needed a bottle; it wasn't hard to find someone's older brother or sister to go buy it. I sure today's youths are just as 'clever' as we were.

So as long as alcohol is sold in stand alone stores this whole “Think of the Children” argument is invalid versus the current system...